high-court-rebukes-indore-police-over-custody:rape-accused’s-son-kept-handcuffed-for-30-hours;-court-slams-illegal-detention-and-questions-conduct

Madhya Pradesh High Court’s Indore Bench strongly reprimanded the city police for illegally detaining and handcuffing Raja Dubey, son of rape-accused real estate businessman Sanjay Dubey. The police kept him inside the police station for nearly 30 hours, prompting the court to remark: “You handcuffed him—why not put shackles on him too?” The division bench has directed the Police Commissioner to begin a departmental inquiry and register a criminal case against the TI and the police personnel responsible. A detailed report must be submitted to the court within two weeks. The matter reached the court after Raja’s brother-in-law, Akash Tiwari, filed a Habeas Corpus petition through advocate Neeraj Soni. 30 hours in police station, handcuffed; TI fails to justify detention During the hearing, the TI of Chandan Nagar, Indramani Patel, submitted CCTV footage of the 30-hour period after initially claiming he was facing “technical difficulties.” He told the court the handcuffs were used because the police station “remains open” and they feared Raja might run away. However, the court rejected this justification, stating that the police had violated the fundamental rights of the detainee by detaining him illegally for such a long period. Court notes: Evidence is clear, footage confirms illegal custody The bench said, “We have sufficient evidence against you. Tell us clearly—did you hold the boy in custody or not?” When the TI failed to deny it, the court noted it as an admission. The judges pointed out that the CCTV footage clearly showed Raja being kept in custody, handcuffed, and unlawfully detained for 30 hours. Background: Rape case against real estate businessman Indore real estate developer Sanjay Dubey (62) has been booked under the POCSO Act after a minor girl accused him of sexual exploitation and impregnating her. The FIR was registered on 12 November. With the police unable to trace Sanjay, officers allegedly detained his son Raja (32), an engineer, to pressure the family. The officers who took him into custody reportedly identified themselves as Crime Branch personnel. Detained until court hearing was imminent Raja was kept in custody until 11:30 PM on 27 November, and was handcuffed and allegedly humiliated. When the case came up for hearing on 28 November, and the court sought a status report from the state, the police immediately released him. On 2 December, investigating officer Sandhya Nigam appeared before the High Court and claimed Raja had been brought in “for questioning.” When the bench asked how questioning could last 30 hours, she responded that she had been on leave that day and only the TI could explain. Court questions illegal detention duration In the previous hearing, the court had stressed, Questioning may last one or two hours, but how can it continue for 30 hours? The court summoned TI Indramani Patel personally, and directed the state’s counsel to ensure that CCTV footage and all details were properly presented on 4 December.