raisen-bank-manager-acquitted-after-14-months-in-jail:hc-clears-all-charges-in-kisan-credit-fraud-case;-victim-says,-‘friends’-conspiracy-took-my-job-reputation’

My life was going wonderfully. I was a relationship manager at a private bank. My wife was a teacher at a private school where our children also studied. Father had retired from police and settled in the village. Elder sister is also in police. Everything was fine, but in just one day my world was destroyed. These are the words of Abhinav Dubey, a resident of Raisen district. Abhinav worked as a relationship manager at a private bank, his wife was a teacher at a private school where their children studied. His father, after being retired from the police service, lived in the village. His elder sister was also in the police. Abhinav was sentenced to seven years in jail in a fraud case he insists he had no role in. After his arrest, his wife lost her job and moved to her parents’ home with the children. His motorcycle and gold loan accounts defaulted and were auctioned. After spending about 14 months in jail, the High Court has now acquitted him, but the consequences continue to shape his life. Read the full report by Dainik Bhaskar.. HC acquits Abhinav On November 18, the High Court overturned the district court’s decision, giving Abhinav a clean chit. The court stated that the handwriting report could not be considered credible evidence and noted the absence of direct involvement by Abhinav. He walked free after 14 months in jail. However, he says freedom has come at a cost: I lost my job, my wife lost hers, and my financial life collapsed. Even though I am innocent, it will take years to rebuild my life. How the case began? Abhinav worked as a Relationship Manager (RM) at ICICI Bank in Narsinghpur, where his primary responsibility was processing Kisan Credit Cards (KCC) for farmers. In 2016, his colleague Sumit Thakur approached him, saying that his friend Ram Lodhi urgently needed a KCC loan for five acres of agricultural land. Abhinav asked for the standard documents, land records, Patwari and Gram Secretary signatures, Aadhaar card and PAN card. Sumit arranged the file. As per procedure, the documents underwent internal scrutiny, followed by physical verification, and everything appeared correct. The loan was approved. Abhinav moved on to other assignments, unaware that a series of events would soon turn his life upside down. Police arrive 3 years later Three years after the loan was processed, in 2019, a complaint was lodged at Kotwali police station, Narsinghpur. The complainant, Sugar Bai, claimed that a loan of ₹5.69 lakh had been fraudulently taken on her land using fake documents. She alleged that ‘Ram Lodhi’ and the bank officials had colluded to obtain the loan and split the money. Abhinav recalls, When I saw the loan file at the police station and then saw the complainant, I was shocked. A large conspiracy had taken shape around me. How the fraud was executed? The police investigation uncovered a chain of manipulations. Sumit and his two friends, Yash Sharma and Pradeep Lodhi, were under personal debt and looking for money. They somehow acquired the original land records belonging to Sugar Bai and devised a plan. The land records listed Ram Lodhi, Sugar Bai’s husband, as the owner. The conspirators decided to create a fake identity. They used Yash Sharma’s photo and forged Aadhaar, PAN, voter ID and even a Sarpanch certificate in the name of ‘Ram Lodhi’. The verification process was compromised further as the Sarpanch and Village Secretary authenticated these documents without proper checks. Another woman, Babli Noria, a vegetable vendor, was enlisted to pose as the wife of the fake Ram Lodhi in exchange for money. This ensured seamless processing of the loan. Police focus on Abhinav After the complaint, the investigation shifted toward the bank staff. Initially, the SDOP gave Abhinav a clean chit, stating that physical verification and photographs were handled by other departments. But as the main conspirators, Sumit and Yash, secured anticipatory bail and went missing, the police directed pressure on Abhinav. He was arrested and spent nearly a month in jail before obtaining bail. The investigation continued for years, eventually leading to a chargesheet. District court verdict shocked Abhinav On May 29, 2024, the district court delivered its verdict. Instead of relief, Abhinav faced several setbacks: The conviction relied heavily on a disputed handwritten analysis, in which the expert merely stated that ‘there is a possibility that 3–4 signatures on the file belong to Abhinav.’ The defence argued that the handwriting samples were taken illegally, after the chargesheet was filed and without court approval. Nevertheless, the court upheld the charges, and Abhinav returned to jail. Family’s struggle HC appeal With Abhinav in jail, the family’s situation worsened. His wife had to leave her job and move to her parents’ home with the children. Unable to pay EMIs, his gold loan and bike were auctioned. His credit score collapsed, making financial rehabilitation nearly impossible. The family then appealed to the High Court. Advocate Manoj Chaturvedi presented several arguments: Unanswered questions While the court has cleared him, the case leaves several issues unresolved: